Staff and users of Villefranche-sur-Saône town hall worked together on their future single site

Client
Ville de Villefranche-sur-Saône
Year
2019

The challenge

The Reception and User Relations Department of Villefranche-sur-Saône town hall was preparing to centralise the municipal services on a single site. The current service had to be diagnosed, then the future site defined with the staff and with the users who come there to carry out their formalities.

Staff and users of Villefranche-sur-Saône town hall worked together on their future single site

Project flow

  1. 01. Immersion and first observations
  2. 02. Workshops with the departments: typology and journeys
  3. 03. Observing staff at their workstations
  4. 04. User interviews in the field
  5. 05. Benchmark of similar projects
  6. 06. Co-design workshops with staff and users
  7. 07. Summary and prioritised recommendations

Study detail

We first worked with the two groups separately: the town hall staff, then the users who come there to carry out their formalities. Then we brought them together.

Black and white photo of a workshop in a panelled room: a facilitator standing, a sheet in hand, speaks to participants seated around a table covered with cards

What the staff already know

The staff of the services involved in the project already know the town hall’s visitors through their work. We brought these staff members together in two workshops with the departments to pool this knowledge and turn it into a common frame of reference.

There, they explored the wide range of visitors who come to the town hall in order to draw out a typology of use. Then they mapped the journeys, use case by use case, to spot where the service could improve.

A participant places a sticky note on a large plan pinned to the wall, already covered with columns of orange, green and blue notes
A hand holds a user profile card above journey templates annotated by hand, with green sticky notes
5 consolidated proto-users
12 use cases mapped

At their posts, alongside the staff

We accompanied 15 staff members at their posts. These participant observations were meant to understand in which contexts they interact with users, and what relationship they have with them.

Semi-structured interviews complemented the observation. In them, the staff talked about what could be improved in the organisation and in their workstation, and about what they expect from the future single site.

A staff member at her reception desk fills in a paper form, facing a screen and a printer, while a user waits on a chair at the back of the room

Going to meet users where they pass through

On the users’ side, we carried out on-site interviews to assess the current experience at the town hall and spot the points of friction. These encounters took place in places people pass through: the town hall, the media library and the neighbourhood centres.

The interviews first covered the image they have of the town hall and its staff. The questionnaire asked them, for example, to rate from 0 to 5 whether the words “welcoming”, “reassuring” or “confidential” describe their town hall well. It also covered how they feel about the features of the place and their overall experience.

On the steps of a public building, an interviewer, questionnaire in hand, talks with a passer-by
Town hall questionnaire on a clipboard: feelings about the place, spaces identified, service expected, then a scale from 0 to 5 for words such as professional, welcoming, reassuring or confidential

Inside the Hôtel de Ville, we also analysed the circulation flows. By observing who goes where, we identified types of journeys, recurring or atypical.

A user comes to the reception kiosk for an appointment. The reception agent tells them it is not the right place, then leaves their post to walk them back and show them where they need to go.

Report page 'The other flows': on two plans of the reception area, the atypical journeys in green and where they meet the staff journeys in orange
Report page 'The user in the wrong place': on the plan, the round trip between the entrance and the reception kiosk, in two numbered steps
80+ citizens interviewed
5 visitor journeys identified

Staff and citizens around the same table

We brought staff and citizens together in two co-design workshops, to think together about the organisation and the functions of the future single site.

Co-design workshop in a large room decorated with a painting: participants spread around several tables covered with sticky notes, a facilitator standing

A report and mood boards

The study report brings together the areas for improvement and the recommendations.

Pages of the study report spread out: cover 'Final summary', the engagement in a few figures, the profile of the people interviewed, the engagement schedule and a radar chart

We also ran a benchmark of similar projects and, to inspire the design of the new spaces, put together mood boards by theme.

Mood board: examples of wall-mounted and free-standing signage, counter pictograms, lockers and a wall calendar

While waiting for the single site

The single site did not exist yet. Rather than wait for it to open, we defined experiments to put in place in the meantime, with the performance criteria that will be used to evaluate them.

Participants stick emoticon stickers onto a printed user journey template, next to sheets of stickers

Akiani stepped in on a project in trouble. The combination of their expertise, their ability to listen and their adaptability deserves to be highlighted. It made it possible both to consolidate the project's strategy with the organisation's leadership, while instilling an inclusive experimental momentum on the ground.

Head of Reception and User Relations, Villefranche-sur-Saône town hall

Want to discuss your project?

Let's talk about your stakes, constraints and ambitions so we can build the best user experience together.

Contact us